Officials File Civil Lawsuit against 3 Former Florida Insurance Companies

Apr 2, 2008

Insurance Journal--Apr. 1, 2008

The Florida Department of Financial Services filed a civil lawsuit against the officers, directors and affiliates of three former Florida insurance companies, according to Chief Financial Officer Alex Sink.

Lawyers for DFS, the court-appointed Receiver of Atlantic Preferred Insurance Co., Florida Preferred Property Insurance Co. and Southern Family Insurance Co. (Poe Companies), have now determined the state has the right to recover additional money.

The DFS lawsuit, filed March 28 in the Second Judicial Circuit Court, seeks damages in excess of $100 million from the officers, directors and affiliates of the now-insolvent insurance companies.

"Florida’s insurance consumers were forced to foot the bill when the Poe Companies became insolvent so that policyholders could have their claims paid," Sink said. "We will aggressively pursue any opportunity to recoup additional funds to reduce the assessments levied against Florida’s insurance consumers."

DFS has served as the court-appointed Receiver of the Poe Companies since the Second Judicial Circuit Court ordered the Poe Companies into liquidation on May 31, 2006. As Receiver, DFS took control of the Poe Companies’ operations and liquidated the companies’ assets to pay outstanding claims. More than 320,000 Floridians held insurance policies from one of the Poe Companies when the companies were ordered to be liquidated, and most policies were automatically transferred into Citizens Property Insurance Corp. in July 2006.

The Florida Insurance Guarantee Association, which was established by the Florida Legislature to handle the claims of insolvent insurance companies, has paid $1.2 billion in claims from the three Poe Companies as of Jan. 31.

More than 46,600 policyholder claims have been filed against the Poe Companies, and FIGA expects to pay approximately an additional $123.5 million for claims still needing to be paid. As a result of the Poe Companies’ liquidation and need to pay outstanding claims, FIGA assessments could total approximately $790 million on Floridians’ insurance policyholders.

Additional information about the Poe Companies’ Receivership can be found at

Source: Florida Department of Financial Services